Pinoy Crim
JurisprudenceLaw EnforcementCriminalisticsCrime DetectionSociology of CrimesCorrectional Admin
Practice Exams

Module 8.11: Homicide, Robbery, & Kidnapping Investigation

I. Homicide Investigation

A homicide is the killing of one human being by another. A homicide investigation is arguably the most important and complex investigation a detective will handle.

A. Initial Responsibilities

  • First Responder's Duties: Secure the scene, render aid if possible (though the victim is usually deceased), and identify any witnesses.
  • The "Golden Hour": The period immediately following the discovery of the crime is the most critical. Evidence is fresh, and witnesses' memories are clearest.

B. Key Priorities in a Homicide Investigation

  1. Establish the Cause and Manner of Death:

    • The cause of death is the medical reason for the death (e.g., gunshot wound, stabbing, strangulation). This is determined by the forensic pathologist during the autopsy.
    • The manner of death is the legal classification of the death. There are four main manners:
      • Natural: Death due to disease or old age.
      • Accidental: Unintentional death.
      • Suicide: Intentional self-inflicted death.
      • Homicide: Death at the hands of another.
    • An investigator must first rule out the other three manners to confirm that a homicide has occurred.

  2. Identify the Victim: If the victim is unknown, their identification is a top priority. This can be done through fingerprints, dental records, DNA, or personal effects.

  3. Determine the Motive: Why was the victim killed? Understanding the motive helps to narrow the search for the suspect. Common motives include:

    • Financial Gain: Robbery, insurance fraud.
    • Passion/Jealousy: Crimes involving romantic relationships.
    • Revenge: Retaliation for a past wrong.
    • Elimination: Killing a witness to another crime.

  4. Identify and Apprehend the Perpetrator: The ultimate goal of the investigation.

C. The Importance of the Victim

In a homicide case, the victim cannot speak for themselves. Therefore, a crucial part of the investigation is conducting a thorough "victimology"—a deep dive into the victim's life, background, habits, and relationships. This helps to identify potential suspects and motives.

III. Kidnapping Investigation

Kidnapping is the unlawful taking, holding, or carrying away of a person against their will.

A. The Primary Goal

In a kidnapping investigation, the number one priority is the safe return of the victim. All other considerations, including the apprehension of the suspects, are secondary to the victim's safety.

B. Types of Kidnapping

  1. Kidnapping for Ransom:

    • The classic form of kidnapping where the victim is held in exchange for a monetary demand.
    • Investigative Steps:
      • "Proof of Life": The first step is to confirm that the victim is still alive.
      • Communication: Law enforcement will often coach the family on how to communicate with the kidnappers. The goal is to keep the lines of communication open and to play for time.
      • No-Go on Ransom: Police will strongly advise against paying the ransom, as it does not guarantee the victim's return and encourages more kidnappings.
      • Intelligence Gathering: While the negotiations are ongoing, an intense investigation is launched to identify and locate the kidnappers. The elite PNP Anti-Kidnapping Group (AKG) specializes in these cases.

  2. Kidnapping as part of another crime (e.g., Robbery or Rape): The victim is abducted to facilitate another crime.

  3. Parental/Family Kidnapping: A non-custodial parent takes a child without legal permission. While the motive is different, it is still a serious crime.

C. Investigative Challenges

  • Time is the Enemy: The risk to the victim increases the longer they are held.
  • The Communication Phase: This is the most critical and delicate phase. A mistake in negotiation could endanger the victim.
  • Jurisdictional Issues: The victim may be taken and moved across multiple cities or provinces, requiring coordination between different police units.

Introduction

While the general principles of investigation apply to all crimes, certain serious offenses require specialized knowledge and investigative techniques. This module provides an overview of the investigation of three major "crimes against persons": Homicide, the killing of a human being; Robbery, theft by force or intimidation; and Kidnapping, the unlawful taking and holding of a person. These crimes are among the most feared by the public and are given the highest priority by law enforcement.

Key Learning Objectives:

  • Identify the key priorities and considerations in a homicide investigation.
  • Understand the legal elements of robbery and the importance of the M.O. file.
  • Describe the different types of kidnapping and the primary goal in a kidnapping investigation.
  • Recognize the unique challenges posed by each of these serious crimes.

II. Robbery Investigation

Robbery is the taking of property from a person or from their immediate presence by the use of force, violence, or intimidation. It is a crime against a person, not just a property crime like theft.

A. Legal Elements

To prove robbery, the investigator must establish:

  1. The taking of property.
  2. From the victim or in their presence.
  3. By means of force or fear (intimidation).

B. Classification of Robberies

  • Street Robbery: (e.g., "holdup," "mugging"). The most common type.
  • Commercial Robbery: Robbery of a business like a bank, convenience store, or gas station.
  • Residential Robbery: (e.g., "home invasion"). Robbery that occurs in a person's home. This is particularly dangerous.
  • Armored Car Robbery: A highly planned and often violent crime targeting high-value assets.

C. Investigative Considerations

  1. Responding with Caution: Robbery is an inherently violent crime, and suspects may still be at or near the scene and armed. Officer safety is paramount.
  2. Witness Descriptions: The most important evidence in a robbery case is often the victim's and witnesses' description of the suspect and any getaway vehicle. The investigator must obtain a detailed description as soon as possible.
  3. The Modus Operandi (M.O.): Robbers are creatures of habit. They often use the same methods in every crime they commit. The Modus Operandi (M.O.) or "method of operation" includes:
    • The type of location targeted.
    • The day of the week and time of day.
    • The type of weapon used.
    • The words they say ("This is a stickup!").
    • How they control the victims.
    • How they make their getaway.
  • The M.O. File: Investigators maintain M.O. files to link different robberies to the same suspect or group (a "robbery series"). This is a key tool for identifying serial robbers.
  1. Physical Evidence: This includes fingerprints, DNA from a mask or clothing, and surveillance video from the location.

Conclusion

Homicide, robbery, and kidnapping are high-stakes investigations that test the limits of an investigator's skill, patience, and courage. A homicide investigation is a deep dive into a life that was cut short, seeking justice for the deceased. A robbery investigation is a race to identify a dangerous and often repetitive offender based on their method of operation. A kidnapping investigation is a delicate and time-sensitive operation where the primary focus is always on bringing the victim home safely. While each crime presents unique challenges, they all require the same foundation: a thorough, systematic, and evidence-based approach to finding the truth.