Pinoy Crim
JurisprudenceLaw EnforcementCriminalisticsCrime DetectionSociology of CrimesCorrectional Admin
Practice Exams

Module 7.15: Forensic Psychology & Criminal Profiling

I. The Field of Forensic Psychology

Forensic psychologists are practitioners of psychology who apply their skills to the legal system. Their work is varied and can occur at all stages of the criminal justice process.

Common Roles of a Forensic Psychologist:

  1. Assessment and Evaluation: This is a major part of the field.

    • Competency to Stand Trial: Assessing whether a defendant understands the legal proceedings and can assist in their own defense.
    • Insanity Defense Evaluations: Assessing the defendant's mental state at the time of the offense.
    • Risk Assessment: Evaluating the likelihood that an offender will re-offend in the future (e.g., for parole decisions).
    • Child Custody Evaluations: Making recommendations in divorce cases.

  2. Consultation with Law Enforcement:

    • Providing training to police on topics like crisis intervention, stress management, and dealing with mentally ill individuals.
    • Assisting with hostage negotiations.
    • Assisting with criminal profiling.

  3. Treatment:

    • Providing psychological treatment to individuals in correctional facilities.
    • Providing treatment to victims of crime.

  4. Expert Witness Testimony:

    • Testifying in court on any of the assessment topics listed above, offering their expert opinion to the judge and jury.

III. The Profiling Process

The process of creating a profile involves a rigorous analysis of all available information about the crime.

1. Profiling Inputs: This is the data collection phase. The profiler gathers:

  • Crime Scene Photos and Sketches: To analyze the physical evidence and its layout.
  • Autopsy Reports (Medico-Legal Reports): To understand the nature of the victim's injuries and cause of death.
  • Complete Victimology: A thorough investigation of the victim's background, lifestyle, habits, and relationships. Who was this person and why were they chosen?
  • Police Reports: To get the full narrative of the investigation so far.

2. Decision Process Models: The profiler analyzes the inputs, looking for meaningful patterns and asking key questions:

  • What was the offender's primary motive?
  • How much risk did the offender take?
  • What was the sequence of acts during the crime?

3. Crime Assessment: The profiler reconstructs the behavior of the offender and the victim. Was the crime organized or disorganized? What was the motive?

4. The Criminal Profile: The profiler creates the actual profile, which will include hypotheses about the offender's:

  • Demographics: Age range, race, sex.
  • Personality: Intelligent, impulsive, aggressive, etc.
  • Behavioral Habits: Lifestyle, occupation.
  • Recommendations to the Investigation: The profile will often include strategies for how to identify and apprehend the suspect (e.g., where to look, what kind of interrogation techniques might be effective).

Conclusion

Forensic psychology brings the insights of human behavior into the legal system, performing crucial roles from assessing competency to consulting with police. Criminal profiling is one specific application of this expertise, offering a glimpse into the mind of an unknown offender. It is an attempt to infer the "who" from the "how." While not the infallible science often portrayed in fiction, profiling provides a structured way for investigators to make educated guesses, helping to bring focus to a complex investigation and offering a behavioral compass to guide the search for a violent criminal.

Introduction

Forensic Psychology is the application of the science and profession of psychology to questions and issues relating to the law and the legal system. It is a broad field that encompasses a wide range of activities. One of the most well-known, and often mythologized, of these activities is Criminal Profiling. This is an investigative tool used by law enforcement to identify the likely characteristics of an unknown offender based on the way they committed a particular crime. This module will provide an overview of the field of forensic psychology and then focus on the process and application of criminal profiling.

Key Learning Objectives:

  • Define Forensic Psychology and describe the various roles of a forensic psychologist.
  • Define Criminal Profiling and understand its purpose as an investigative tool.
  • Differentiate between organized and disorganized crime scenes.
  • Explain the basic inputs and goals of the criminal profiling process.
  • Understand the limitations and scientific validity of profiling.

II. Criminal Profiling: An Investigative Tool

Definition: Criminal Profiling, also known as offender profiling or criminal investigative analysis, is an investigative strategy used to help identify the personality, behavioral, and demographic characteristics of an unknown offender based on an analysis of the crime scene.

Purpose: The primary purpose of a profile is not to identify a specific person, but to narrow down a pool of suspects and to give investigators a better idea of the type of person they should be looking for. It is an aid to investigation, not a solution.

A. When is Profiling Used?

Profiling is most often used in cases where the offender has demonstrated some form of psychopathology, particularly in cases of:

  • Serial homicide or rape.
  • Bizarre crimes.
  • Arson.
  • Bombing.

The key is that the crime scene should reflect something about the offender's unique personality or behavior.

B. The Organized/Disorganized Dichotomy

This is a classic classification system developed by the FBI's Behavioral Science Unit. It proposes that offenders can be broadly categorized based on the state of their crime scene.

1. The Organized Crime Scene

  • Characteristics:
    • The crime appears to have been planned.
    • The victim is a targeted stranger.
    • The scene is controlled; there is little mess.
    • The body is hidden or moved from the scene.
    • The weapon is removed from the scene.
  • Inferred Profile of the Organized Offender:
    • Intelligence: Average to above-average intelligence.
    • Socially Competent: Has a job, friends, may be married or have a family.
    • Geographically Mobile: Lives some distance from the crime and uses a vehicle.
    • Follows the Crime in the Media: Takes an interest in the police investigation.
    • Example: Ted Bundy.

2. The Disorganized Crime Scene

  • Characteristics:
    • The crime appears spontaneous and unplanned.
    • The victim is known or a victim of opportunity.
    • The scene is messy and chaotic.
    • The body is left at the scene.
    • The weapon is often improvised and left at the scene.
  • Inferred Profile of the Disorganized Offender:
    • Intelligence: Below-average intelligence.
    • Socially Inadequate: Unemployed, a loner, lives alone.
    • Geographically Stable: Lives or works near the crime scene.
    • Minimal Interest in the police investigation.
    • Often has a history of mental illness.

Board Exam Tip: This dichotomy is a foundational concept in profiling. Be able to list the characteristics of both the crime scene and the inferred offender profile for each type.

IV. Validity and Limitations

While made famous by movies and television, criminal profiling is a controversial technique with significant limitations.

  • An Art, Not a Science: Profiling is based on experience, intuition, and statistical probabilities, not on hard scientific principles like DNA analysis. The "organized/disorganized" model is a helpful guide but is not universally applicable; many offenders show a mix of traits.
  • Not Admissible in Court: A criminal profile cannot be used as evidence in court to prove a person's guilt. Its purpose is purely investigative.
  • Potential for Misdirection: A poorly constructed profile can send an investigation in the wrong direction, causing police to focus on the wrong type of suspect and ignore the real offender.

Despite these limitations, when used properly as one tool among many, profiling can be a valuable asset. It can help investigators think strategically about a case, prioritize leads, and develop a plan for interviewing suspects.